1987 JTR(SC) 636
1990 4 SCC 697 ; 1991 SCC(L&S) 703
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K.Jagannatha Shetty : M.H.Kania : O.Chinnappa Reddy
State Of U.P.
Versus
Chhotey Lal Pandey
Case No. : 577 of 1979
Date of Decision : 8/11/87
Act Referred :CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.15(4), Art.16(4)
Posts of Munsifs - Backward classes had not been properly identified - Court think, it is really unnecessary to go into the merits of this appeal. The orders of the government of Uttar Pradesh identifying the backward classes for recruitment of posts of Munsifs were struck down on the ground that the backward classes had not been properly identified – Held, Court are told that subsequently another Commission had been appointed to go into that question and the Commission has submitted a report and it is stated to be under the consideration of the State government. We, therefore, do not think it necessary to go into the merits of the appeal – Appeal is dismissed
Posts of Munsifs - Backward classes had not been properly identified - Court think, it is really unnecessary to go into the merits of this appeal. The orders of the government of Uttar Pradesh identifying the backward classes for recruitment of posts of Munsifs were struck down on the ground that the backward classes had not been properly identified – Held, Court are told that subsequently another Commission had been appointed to go into that question and the Commission has submitted a report and it is stated to be under the consideration of the State government. We, therefore, do not think it necessary to go into the merits of the appeal – Appeal is dismissed
(1) WE think, it is really unnecessary to go into the merits of this appeal. The orders of the government of Uttar Pradesh identifying the backward classes for recruitment of posts of Munsifs were struck down on the ground that the backward classes had not been properly identified. We are told that subsequently another Commission had been appointed to go into that question and the Commission has submitted a report and it is stated to be under the consideration of the State government. We, therefore, do not think it necessary to go into the merits of the appeal. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed. No costs.