1953 JTR(SC) 52
1956 AIR(SC) 745
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
17th April 1953
M. PATANJALI SASTRI, CJI., B.K. MUKHERJEA, S.R. DAS AND GHULAM HASAN JJ.
Lloyds Bank. Ltd. - Appellants.
Versus
The Lloyds Bank Indian Staff Association and others ... Respondents.
Civil Appeal No. 79 of 1953.
Act Referred :CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.136
Article 136-No retrospective operation.
Held1: "The objection is that the award was passed on 5-1-1950 and was published under S. 17, Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, by the Government in a notification of the Ministry of Labour dated 17.1.1950 and was also declared binding on the same day for a period of one year. Article 136 has, therefore, no application to the award as it has been held by this Court that the said article has no retrospective operation.
The preliminary objection is allowed (per Patanjali Sastri C.J.)
Held1: "The objection is that the award was passed on 5-1-1950 and was published under S. 17, Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, by the Government in a notification of the Ministry of Labour dated 17.1.1950 and was also declared binding on the same day for a period of one year. Article 136 has, therefore, no application to the award as it has been held by this Court that the said article has no retrospective operation.
The preliminary objection is allowed (per Patanjali Sastri C.J.)
Judgement
Patanjali Sastri, C.J.I. This is an appeal by Special Leave from an award of the All India Industrial Tribunal (Bank Disputes).
2. A preliminary objection is raised to the maintainability of this appeal, the liberty to raise such objection having been reserved to the respondents at the time when Special leave was granted to the appellants. The objection is that the award was passed on 5.1.1950 and was published under S. 17, Industrial Disputes Act,1947, by the Government in a notification of the Ministry of Labour dated 17.1.1950 and was also declared binding on the same day for a period of one year. Article 136 has, therefore, no application to the award as it has been held by this Court that the said article has no retrospective operation. This is not disputed by Mr. S. Chaudhuri but he argues that the award was really published only on 28.1.1950, when the notification referred to above appeared in the Gazette of India. We see no force in this argument. The preliminary objection is allowed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
For Citation : AIR 1956 SC 745